College Application Narratives

This project aims to answer some common and uncommon questions about college admissions using personal narratives from college students who have been through this journey.

These responses are intentionally personal. We hope to provide more than facts and anecdotes you can hear everywhere. Here, you can hear factual, but maybe not so exciting, stories, to guide your college application journey.

Remember, these stories don’t reflect “the way” to apply to colleges. I quote one of the respondents here: “having gone through the [college application] process” doesn’t mean [college students] actually know how it works. Nonetheless, we hope this project can be of use for you in your application journey.

Questions

Question 1

How do you choose where to apply?

Brown University, Class of 2028, Major: APMA-CS; pre-med

"I had a list of 'safety', 'target', and 'reach' schools."

I followed the standard suggestion I heard, which is to have a set of "safety", "target", and "reach" schools. I didn't have many other factors that influenced where I applied. I applied to my state's public colleges for safety; schools with strong STEM programs as target schools; and top 20s for reach schools. I also applied to the UC schools.

Brown University, Class of 2028, Major: Sociology; Math

"I factored in application difficulty vs. time spent..."

I'm based in California, so naturally, I applied to the UC schools. As far as other schools, I factored in application difficulty vs. time spent on application when creating my list of "safety", "target", and "reach" schools. Also specifically, I toured Harvard and felt the vibes were off, so I didn't apply there.

Amherst College, Class of 2029, Major: Philosophy

"I made a big list, then did research on if there's anything off-putting."

My process was very vibes based. I made a list of 40 schools, of which I could imagine myself being in. Then I did research on if any of the schools had anything off-putting. Some of my reasons of putting a school in my list are location and strength in a subject I'm interested in.

University of Pittsburgh, Class of 2028, Major: Computer Science

"I applied to in-state universities because of tuition, and also reach schools strong in CS."

I mostly thought of applying to in-state universities because of in-state tuition. After that, I went for reach schools that were strong in the CS department, like MIT, Stanford and such.

University of Richmond, Class of 2029, Major: Undecided

"I focused on in-state schools because of strong aid for low-income Virginia residents."

I'm from Virginia, and I mostly looked at in-state schools because Virginia schools have pretty good aid for low-income here. I think at University of Richmond, Virginia residents with income under $75,000 can get a full ride. And this was a primary motivation behind my choices.

Carnegie Mellon University, Class of 2030, Major: Visual Arts

"Student culture and school size were my biggest factors."

I value student culture in a college the most, and I also like bigger schools. And those were the primary influences when I chose my schools.

University of Pittsburgh, Class of 2028, Majors: Political Science; Philosophy; Law; Criminal Justice; and Society

"I had a healthy mix of safety, target, and reach schools based on my GPA and preferences."

I had a healthy mix of safety, target, and reach schools. But I also based my choices on my GPA and preferences. I also didn't apply to many Ivy Leagues because they didn't fit my vibe.

University of Michigan, Class of 2028, Major: Mechanical Engineering; Math minor

"I chose schools based on family guidance and engineering program strength."

The places I chose were based on my family's vision of what colleges I need to go to. I also applied for specific programs that were very good for engineering. I'd say the influence between parental guidance and program strength was half-and-half.

Question 2

Did you apply early decision to any schools? If so, how did you choose the school?

Brown University, Class of 2028, Major: Sociology; Math

"I chose my early school based on environment, prestige, and school size."

I applied ED to Brown and ED2 to Pomona College. I kind of knew they were my top choices because of environment, prestige, and a smaller school size.

Amherst College, Class of 2029, Major: Philosophy

"I applied ED to Brown because of the open curriculum and employment outlook."

I applied ED to Brown. I chose Brown because I wanted to do whatever I wanted, and the open curriculum fits that. It also has a good enough prestige, which is a good tool if I want to get employment after.

University of Pittsburgh, Class of 2028, Major: Computer Science

"I chose not to apply early decision anywhere, though I did apply non-restrictive early action."

I chose not to apply early decision anywhere. I kind of figured that I didn't feel too strongly about any individual school. But in hindsight, it might have been worth it to just shoot my shot at a school. I did apply non-restrictive early action to schools in my list that had it.

Carnegie Mellon University, Class of 2030, Major: Visual Arts

"I chose UVA early decision because of its size and student culture."

I applied ED to University of Virginia because I like that it's a bigger school and has nice student culture. Since I'm really interested in student culture and community, I made this decision by following online accounts of the schools I was considering and found which one fit me the most.

Brown University, Class of 2027, Major: IAPA; Classics; Archaeology

"I applied because of departmental strength and open curriculum."

I applied ED to Brown. Since I knew I was going for classics, Brown was a natural choice because it has a really good classics program. I also knew that I wanted to do multiple things, so the open curriculum really fit my needs.

University of Michigan, Class of 2028, Major: Mechanical Engineering; Math minor

"I chose CMU early decision after attending a summer program there."

I applied early decision to CMU and actually got in, but I actually couldn't take the offer because of financial reasons. I chose CMU because I did a summer program there, SAMS, and that was really the first time I got to see students with similar backgrounds and interests.

Question 3

How did you choose a major, and did you stick with it?

Brown University, Class of 2028, Major: APMA-CS; pre-med

"I just chose whatever fit my portfolio the best."

I really didn't have an idea of what to apply as, so I just applied as BME (Biomedical Engineering) since I had biology olympiad experience. As a matter of fact, I just chose whatever fit my portfolio the best. During college though, I decided that engineering was a bad idea and switched to APMA.

Brown University, Class of 2028, Major: Sociology; Math

"I chose my major because it resonated with my essays and portfolio."

I chose sociology when I applied and I did stick with it. I chose sociology because it resonated with my essays and portfolio in healthcare inequalities and stuff like that. I guess I could've also chosen public health, but I chose sociology in the end because I think it covers a broader area of my interest, and I also didn't want to go into the full medical track.

Amherst College, Class of 2029, Major: Philosophy

"I applied with a wide range of majors and declared with philosophy for now."

I applied in the range of philosophy, religion, French, psychology, and linguistics, which are all, broadly, my interests. I declared philosophy in my first semester in college because I wanted to have an anchor. But I'm still exploring other majors as well.

University of Pittsburgh, Class of 2028, Major: Computer Science

"I always wanted to do computer science."

I always wanted to do computer science, so I didn't really think too hard about it and applied as CS for all the schools.

University of Richmond, Class of 2029, Major: Undecided

"I applied undecided."

I actually didn't choose a major. I applied undecided.

Carnegie Mellon University, Class of 2030, Major: Visual Arts

"I chose visual arts because my arts background felt stronger."

I had a really tough time choosing between visual arts and psychology. I applied psychology for UVA, but other than that, I mostly applied as visual arts because I felt like I had a stronger background in arts. For CMU specifically, I applied visual arts because I liked their art program and integration with technology.

Brown University, Class of 2027, Major: IAPA; Classics; Archaeology

"I applied as classics and archaeology, and I later added IAPA."

I applied classics and also put archaeology as my second major. My story with classics was in high school, my English teacher had a classics degree, and he taught a classics class. He's like one of those once-in-a-lifetime teachers, and it really made me interested in the subject. Here at Brown, I also picked up IAPA because I also have an interest in modern politics.

University of Michigan, Class of 2028, Major: Mechanical Engineering; Math minor

"I chose mechanical engineering because I liked CAD, design, and manufacturing."

I was choosing between mechanical engineering and civil engineering. In the end, I chose and stuck with mechanical engineering because of my interest in CAD, design, and manufacturing.

Question 4

How did you pay for college?

Brown University, Class of 2028, Major: APMA-CS; pre-med

"My parents were able to pay for my college."

I'm really fortunate to say that my parents were able to pay for all of my tuition.

Amherst College, Class of 2029, Major: Philosophy

"Mostly parents, plus a very small portion of federal financial aid."

Mostly parents, plus a very small portion of federal financial aid.

University of Richmond, Class of 2029, Major: Undecided

"Financial aid covered my tuition and school-related expenses."

I didn't pay anything tuition-wise; I received full financial aid for tuition and school-related expenses.

University of Pittsburgh, Class of 2028, Majors: Political Science; Philosophy; Law; Criminal Justice; and Society

"A mix of FAFSA aid, loans, and parental contribution."

I took aid and loan from FAFSA. I also had parental contribution, it's a mix of the two.

University of Michigan, Class of 2028, Major: Mechanical Engineering; Math minor

"Scholarships covered most of my costs, with the rest from my parents."

I'm paying mostly through scholarships from UMich. I actually received a lot of merit scholarships because I applied early action. It's roughly a 2:1 split between scholarships and my parents. I actually also applied for a lot of external scholarships, such as ethnic-specific scholarships, writing competitions, and stuff like that.

Question 5

What kind of documents did you need for financial aid? Were there difficulties in obtaining them?

Amherst College, Class of 2029, Major: Philosophy

"The documents were manageable to get, but there were a lot of them."

They asked for so many things: tax filing from two years prior, income documentation, proof of employment and specific household information from my parents. All of that information also has to be routed through College Board/FAFSA.

University of Pittsburgh, Class of 2028, Majors: Political Science; Philosophy; Law; Criminal Justice; and Society

"Lots of documents, but it wasn't too difficult because I had them organized."

I remember having to get W2 forms, tax forms, taxpayer numbers, etc. They weren't difficult to find, mostly because I had them organized already.

University of Michigan, Class of 2028, Major: Mechanical Engineering; Math minor

"I had to research FAFSA carefully because my parents were unfamiliar with the process."

I had to get financial documents and information from my parents to put into FAFSA. Because my parents are immigrants and don't really know how to do these things, and I had to do a lot of research by myself to make sure I'm submitting the FAFSA correctly.

Question 6

When did you start your college application, and what was your timeline?

Brown University, Class of 2028, Major: APMA-CS; pre-med

"I didn't think about college applications until junior year."

I vaguely started knowing about college applications in middle school, but I really didn't care about it until junior year of high school. I started preparing for the SAT in my junior year, asked for recommendation letters at the end of junior year, and started writing my essays in the summer before senior year. The essays and applications continued all the way until the end of regular decisions.

Brown University, Class of 2028, Major: Sociology; Math

"I started thinking about applications early, but it didn't affect me until later in high school."

I started writing my application in senior year of high school, but I guess I started thinking about colleges since the start of high school. I had a sister who was four years older, so my parents kind of started reminding me about college applications early, though it didn't really affect me in freshman and sophomore years.

Amherst College, Class of 2029, Major: Philosophy

"I started thinking about it in freshman year, but didn't start until the summer before senior year."

I started thinking about the application in freshman year of high school. I took my SAT in my sophomore year, but I didn't start with the actual application until the summer before senior year.

University of Pittsburgh, Class of 2028, Major: Computer Science

"I started by applying for my higher priority schools, and then repurposed my existing essays for other schools."

I started my application halfway through the summer before my senior year. I started by looking at schools that had rolling decisions and honors colleges which were a higher priority for me. After those were done, I repurposed my existing essays for the other schools closer to the deadline. I think I finalized my essays about a week before all the deadlines.

Carnegie Mellon University, Class of 2030, Major: Visual Arts

"I started in late June but still submitted pretty last-minute."

I think I started everything in late June. But honestly, I procrastinated quite a bit and submitted my applications pretty last-minute.

Brown University, Class of 2027, Major: IAPA; Classics; Archaeology

"I started seriously working on my application the summer before senior year and submitted in October."

I kind of knew about applying to colleges from a young age. But I really started working on my application in June of the summer before senior year. I put together my first draft in August, did the Brown video essay in September, and submitted the application in October.

University of Pittsburgh, Class of 2028, Majors: Political Science; Philosophy; Law; Criminal Justice; and Society

"I started thinking about college in high school; eventually submitted my applications from August to November."

My first thought about college was at the start of high school. The first time it really affected me in school was sophomore year, where I realized I needed to study and prepare for college. I think I started my application in the summer before senior year, and I submitted my first application in August because it was rolling decisions, and I stopped applying in November.

University of Michigan, Class of 2028, Major: Mechanical Engineering; Math minor

"I started researching in 9th grade and kept building my application throughout high school."

The first time I knew about colleges was in 6th grade. But since my parents never attended college, it remained just an early idea for me. I really started doing research about college applications in 9th grade. In 10th grade, I started writing my personal statement. I also realized I wasn't doing anything outside of classes, so I started doing some extracurriculars as well. In 11th grade, I really honed in on my extracurriculars and applied for programs colleges offer. When 12th grade rolled around, I asked my teachers to read through my essays and finalized my application.

Question 7

Who did you ask for recommendation letters?

Brown University, Class of 2028, Major: APMA-CS; pre-med

"Math and English teacher, because I had the best relationship with them."

Outside of the required counselor recommendation letter, I asked for recommendation letters from my math and English teacher. I read somewhere that you should have your two teacher recommendations be from two non-adjacent subjects, and I figured I had the best relationship with my math teacher in STEM classes, and English teacher in non-STEM classes.

Brown University, Class of 2028, Major: Sociology; Math

"I asked teachers who knew me well, plus my mock trial coach."

I asked my history teacher from freshman and junior year. He was also a club moderator for a club I was in, so I felt like he could give a helpful perspective. I also asked my math teacher because that was my favorite subject at the time and I participated frequently in the class. I also actually had an additional letter from my mock trial coach.

Amherst College, Class of 2029, Major: Philosophy

"Math/CS teacher and philosophy teacher, who saw my growth in high school. Also a professor from online research."

I asked my math and CS teacher, who taught me for three years. I felt his class challenged me the most; I always walk out of his class dead, in a good way. I also asked my philosophy teacher, who taught me and also saw me through my ethics bowl stuff, which was one of the biggest struggles I had in high school. I also had a letter from a professor at another college who I did online research with.

Brown University, Class of 2027, Major: IAPA; Classics; Archaeology

"I asked my Latin and English teachers."

I asked my Latin and English teacher. I feel like those two were the teachers whom I had the most developed relationships with outside of the classroom. Also, on the topic of suggesting to have recommendation letters from different subject areas, I think it didn't apply to me as much because I was applying for two humanities degrees. I also think it helped show me as someone who kind of knows the direction they're going.

University of Pittsburgh, Class of 2028, Majors: Political Science; Philosophy; Law; Criminal Justice; and Society

"I asked my English, philosophy teacher, and someone from a youth organization."

I asked my English and philosophy teachers for recommendation letters because I did well in their classes and also had good relationships with them. I also asked one of the people in a youth organization I was participating in. I had strong connections with them and strong qualifications in that area.

University of Michigan, Class of 2028, Major: Mechanical Engineering; Math minor

"I asked STEM and humanities teachers to speak to different strengths."

I feel like my specific background comes with some stereotypes, also especially because I'm applying in STEM. So I had a tactic where I asked two STEM teachers and two humanities teachers, and asked one of each to talk about my personal strength, and the other to talk about my academic strength.

Question 8

Who helped you with your college application?

Brown University, Class of 2028, Major: APMA-CS; pre-med

"English teacher, dad."

My English teacher and my dad both helped me proofread my essays. My dad also helped me do school research on which schools to apply. Other than that, I was in brief contact with a college advising company, but I didn't end up working with them. My school also provided college counselors, but they weren't super useful for me.

Brown University, Class of 2028, Major: Sociology; Math

"My mom, sister, and school counselor."

My mom reminded me about college and planning ahead for applications. My sister helped look at my essays. I had some interaction with my college counselor in school as well; they looked at my college list and actually suggested ROTC to me, which I didn't do.

Amherst College, Class of 2029, Major: Philosophy

"Graduated students, parents, paid college advising company."

I remember some graduated students who helped me choose schools. My parents were also somewhat involved in the process. Most help came from an external paid college advising company. It was very much of an out of school operation.

University of Pittsburgh, Class of 2028, Major: Computer Science

"My father and my literature class teacher."

I think the most help I got was from my father who read over a lot of my essays. He also helped me edit them before submitting. My literature class teacher also had us submit our personal statement and give feedback on those as well.

Brown University, Class of 2027, Major: IAPA; Classics; Archaeology

"I mostly relied on my college counselor and my own sense of voice."

Beyond my college counselor who gave me good general advice and knowledge about applications, I didn't really get much other help. I didn't feel like other people were able to speak for me.

University of Pittsburgh, Class of 2028, Majors: Political Science; Philosophy; Law; Criminal Justice; and Society

"My college advisor helped with the technical side, and my family and friends read my essays."

My college advisor from high school helped me a lot with the technical side of the process, like dealing with CommonApp, getting documents for different schools, and stuff like that. I also had my family and friends read my essays.

University of Michigan, Class of 2028, Major: Mechanical Engineering; Math minor

"A CMU admissions officer really helped me with the process; my parents and my English teacher also contributed."

I took a leap when I participated in a summer program at CMU by talking to an admissions officer there for the CS department. She helped me check my essays and extracurriculars, even had a one-on-one zoom call with me to go through each sentence of my personal statement. Other than that, I received a lot of motivation from my parents, and I also had my English teacher help read my essays.

Question 9

How did you frame your application?

Brown University, Class of 2028, Major: APMA-CS; pre-med

"Biomedical engineer interested in natural sciences."

I had plenty of olympiad experiences during high school, such as in computer science, math, and biology, so I mainly centered my application around those. I also included chess as my main hobby outside of academics, but that was about it. I would say I presented myself as a biomedical engineer who was interested in natural sciences.

Brown University, Class of 2028, Major: Sociology; Math

"Someone who cares about other people and the broader society."

I presented myself as someone who cares about other people and the broader society. I focused on my observations about things that were going on around me in detail and engaged with them on a deeper level.

Amherst College, Class of 2029, Major: Philosophy

"An application is a fiction based on reality."

I think an application is not nonfiction. It's fiction based on reality. In that regard, if you want to make a character memorable, you have to give them backstories that are tragic or funny. Which is why I chose a tragic and funny one. I wanted to be seen as a nerd, but for good reasons, not because I want to go to some university, but because I'm somehow born and disposed to being that way.

University of Pittsburgh, Class of 2028, Major: Computer Science

"I framed my application around my passion for math and CS."

I was really interested in math and CS stuff, so I tried to frame it around my passion for math and CS. In hindsight though, I think I probably should've knit some of my other activities in that would differentiate me from the crowd.

Carnegie Mellon University, Class of 2030, Major: Visual Arts

"I tried to show that I valued community."

I really valued community, and I wanted colleges to know that. I've really tried to show that point through my personal statement and extracurriculars. Also, for my art portfolio, I also made sure that messages related to humility and empathy get across.

Brown University, Class of 2027, Major: IAPA; Classics; Archaeology

"I wanted every part of my application to match a bigger story."

I wanted to present myself in two ways: who I am, and where I am going. And I was really concerned with every part of the application matching up with a bigger story that's authentic to myself. I think people sometimes get scared thinking that another person's on the other side, but as weird as this may sound, the admissions officer knows you're still a kid, so I took advantage of that to have some fun.

University of Pittsburgh, Class of 2028, Majors: Political Science; Philosophy; Law; Criminal Justice; and Society

"I presented my niche through political participation and youth organization work."

An important thing for me was presenting myself as a sort of a niche thing. It's not just about having a strong application in terms of standardized tests and grades, but also in ways you engage your society and community as a whole. In my application, I really emphasized my political participation and involvement in youth organizations.

University of Michigan, Class of 2028, Major: Mechanical Engineering; Math minor

"I focused on my story and background of overcoming adversity."

I think I might not be the most extraordinary in academics, so I honed in on my story and my background of overcoming adversity, which I think are my strengths.

Question 10

Any general tips/words for younger students?

Brown University, Class of 2028, Major: APMA-CS; pre-med

"Start your college essays early!"

Arguably, one of the most important components of your college application outside of activities and grades is your essay. Make sure you start early on those. Personally, I had over 10 versions of my personal statement essay, with some complete rewrites!

Brown University, Class of 2028, Major: Sociology; Math

"Try to center your application around a theme/subject."

Really put forward what you're interested in. If it's hard to figure out your exact interest, you should still try to center your application around a theme/subject. Also, remember you can exaggerate in your application, but don't lie!

Amherst College, Class of 2029, Major: Philosophy

"Don't spend too much time on your safety schools."

For individual students, they should avoid being tutored by current college students. Just because they've been through the process doesn't mean they know how it works. Also, don't spend too much time on your safety schools, since you will most likely get in.

University of Pittsburgh, Class of 2028, Major: Computer Science

"The process is stressful, but you will generally end up okay."

I was really stressed during the application season about things like getting into a really prestigious college. But now that I'm in my second year of college, I've found myself to be doing pretty well. So yeah, I think as stressful as the application season may be, you will generally end up okay.

University of Richmond, Class of 2029, Major: Undecided

"Start thinking about essays early, reach out for help if needed, and research and visit colleges."

You should at least start thinking about your essays in the summer before senior year. Also make sure to reach out for help if you need it. Research the colleges you're applying to, and definitely visit colleges too!

Brown University, Class of 2027, Major: IAPA; Classics; Archaeology

"Have a direction and make your application feel like a cohesive story."

While you don't have to be set, I feel like you should have an idea why you want to go to college, and where you'll be at the end of it. Your application should also be a cohesive story, with different parts of the application being distinct subsections pointing towards the same thing.

University of Pittsburgh, Class of 2028, Majors: Political Science; Philosophy; Law; Criminal Justice; and Society

"Differentiate yourself and stay organized with your documents."

I think you should do something to differentiate yourself from the general population. Maybe through unique extracurriculars, making the admissions officer think you're engaged with your education. Also, you need to be organized with the documents and stuff you're sending to college.

University of Michigan, Class of 2028, Major: Mechanical Engineering; Math minor

"Stay motivated and research how college admissions works."

The most important thing is to have motivation for yourself. Because at the end of the day, where you'll get in really depends on where you want to go. Also really research the admissions process: it always changes and schools care about different things. I did my research on sources like YouTube, web search, and forums, which often had suggestions and instructions on parts of the admissions process.